Deskpad

The Deskpad Manifesto

This document serves to provide clarity around what Deskpad is, and why we built it.

At our core, we believe Deskpad is a mission. We are a group of high school students, and are concerned about AI's impact on education. As profit-motivated AI labs push out better and more sophisticated frontier models, the industries that are slow to adapt have been the ones impacted most deeply. Education, which is built on the core values of transparency and accountability, has been hit particularly hard by AI's continuous evolution. We have witnessed firsthand how our fellow classmates have explicitly taken assignments, uploaded them into ChatGPT, and copied-and-pasted the output back into their documents. This cheating has gotten so bad that schools across the country have had no choice but to ban the use of AI and technology altogether. While I once looked at many of these educators in disdain, after speaking to more than one hundred in my development of Deskpad, I have come to develop a deepening sense of sympathy for the seemingly insurmountable challenges they are currently facing in their classrooms.

What we created Deskpad to do, fundamentally, was to provide an alternative to schools who felt the need to ban AI in the classroom. Deskpad is not anti-AI. We are techno-optimist, of the belief that AI has the potential to do tremendous good for our society, and today's students will be the ones pioneering that change. But all of these benefits will only exist if AI is adopted, and more importantly, adopted in the right way. Schools, to this point, have taken the wrong approach to AI. We believe that the solution to AI's incorporation into education is a guardrailed, transparent approach with both students' and teachers' best interests kept at heart.

The risk with AI in education, of course, is also especially large. The technology that allows a student to learn at a pace never seen before also has the potential to make them incredibly stupid. There is published research that an over-reliance on AI, especially in an academic setting, can erode the part of your brain that thinks critically. If AI is to be adopted in education, there are also immense concerns around AI's environmental impact, student data privacy, and model hallucination on important facts. We believe, however, that several of these risks are mitigated when thoughtful and student-centered adoption is a conscious choice by schools. I will address our perspective on each of the previous concerns below:

On cognitive decline

If every AI model incorporated into the classroom is transparent and guardrailed, this becomes a significantly lower risk. Students who use AI as a “thought partner” are freed to produce their best work while still owning all of the content and ideas. While there will still be a need for some level of student surveillance (as there has been across education's history), in a world where AI's usage is allowed thoughtfully, student cheating will decline. The core idea is that when the technology is encouraged with the student's best interests at heart, students will inherently begin to understand where AI will help or hurt them. In a world where the technology is flat-out prohibited, students will look for loopholes and workarounds, which is where the cognitive offloading truly persists.

On AI's environmental impact

The environmental risks are something we are definitely uncomfortable with pushing away, because we do believe its impacts are legitimate. Training and running large language models can be incredibly energy-consumptive, and it does use significant amounts of energy and water. We believe public outcry against AI in this regard is definitely understandable, especially when it comes to concerns around data-center construction and energy usage. However, what gives us a bit of cautious optimism for the future is that we do believe efficiency is progressing the right way, and that with time, smaller, locally-hosted, and potentially more specialized models can become increasingly capable of doing what once required much larger and environmentally-adverse models. While none of this mitigates the overall environmental impact, we do believe that the responsible path for schools is, if they desire, to adopt it deliberately and intentionally with a full understanding of all of its costs. In other words, we believe schools should not adopt AI just because it seems like “what everyone else is doing”—they should adopt AI intentionally and only in ways they are certain will improve the quality of student learning and contentment.

On student data privacy

While at this point effectively all student messages are being sent to a cloud provider (such as OpenAI, Anthropic, or Google), the world is moving towards locally-hosted models. This means that the LLMs that receive inputted messages run on the messenger's own hardware, such as their computer. There has been promising research done in this space, and Apple themselves have taken the position that AI will run on user-owned hardware in the near future. For education, this means that while we currently have to trust cloud providers when they say they are not misusing student data, we will likely soon live in a world where this is not a concern at all. Furthermore, even current cloud providers are held to extremely rigorous data privacy standards, and there are massive penalties for any corporations found liable for misusing data, especially in the case of students and minors.

On model hallucination

Model hallucination has and will continue to be one of the most challenging issues that AI will face in its adoption. However, as we have seen since the first publicly-available versions of ChatGPT back in late 2022, general hallucination has considerably decreased as the models have improved. In the context of AI in education, recently published peer-reviewed research has also shown that one of the most effective safeguards against hallucination is grounding a model in a trusted, curated body of source material, such as a syllabus or assignment. Studies have shown that in these instances, when the models refer to the source material as opposed to their training data or memory, hallucination rates drop dramatically, in some studies to near zero. Further, other organizations, such as the Chan Zuckerberg funded nonprofit Learning Commons, have created open infrastructure that grounds educational AI systems in trusted curricula and state academic standards, while also providing tools to evaluate the accuracy and instructional quality of AI-generated responses. We are optimistic that with infrastructure like this being developed, and models being grounded in trusted educational source material, AI hallucination will become much less of an issue when it comes to education so that students can learn from the technology without having to second-guess the accuracy and validity of every piece of information they receive.

We believe that if all of these concerns are addressed honestly and diligently, AI truly can change the way people learn for the better. If we live in a world where education and information is truly democratized, our populations will be smarter, happier, and more likely to create positive change. In every instance in human history where education has been made a top priority, the population has thrived. We believe this moment is no different. Our population can either massively benefit, or massively suffer, from the adoption of AI. If we want to benefit, we must band together as a population, and adopt it on our own terms. This is the sole reason for Deskpad's existence, and why we believe it is such an important problem to be solving.

Akshay

Akshay Ganesh, Founder of Deskpad